by hilzoy
Since, as I'm sure you will all be astonished to learn, I am not one of Don Imus' regular listeners, I didn't hear about his unbelievably offensive remarks until today. For those of you who are even more out of it than I am, here they are, in all their glory:
"IMUS: That's some rough girls from Rutgers. Man, they got tattoos and --McGUIRK: Some hard-core hos.
IMUS: That's some nappy-headed hos there. I'm gonna tell you that now, man, that's some -- woo. And the girls from Tennessee, they all look cute, you know, so, like -- kinda like -- I don't know.
McGUIRK: A Spike Lee thing.
IMUS: Yeah.
McGUIRK: The Jigaboos vs. the Wannabes -- that movie that he had."
I wasn't going to write about this -- I mean, honestly, what is there to say? -- until I started reading various responses. For starters, there's this, from Howard Fineman, Newsweek's chief political correspondent:
"You know, the form of humor that you do here is risky, and sometimes it runs off the rails. Most of the people who listen to this show get the joke most of the time, and sometimes, you know, as David Carr said in The New York Times this morning, sometimes you go over the line so far you can't even see the line. And that's what happened in this case."
Curiously, Tom Oliphant used the same metaphor to describe Imus' remarks:
"But even I could see the beginning of what appeared to me to be a riff. And the train went off the tracks, which, you know, can happen to anybody. And, of course, what counts when the train goes off the tracks is what you then do."
The train went off the track? I don't think so. Consider what happens when an actual train derails. There you are, driving it. You approach a curve. Gauging the right speed to take it at is always a bit tricky. This time, you get it wrong, and -- oh my God -- the train goes off the tracks.
Is this in any way analogous to Imus' comments? No. For one thing, he is not piloting a difficult piece of heavy machinery. He is piloting his mouth, which, as an adult, he is expected to be in full control of. For another, there is no perfectly good conversational curve that, if misjudged, might lead normal, decent people to go off the rails in this way. It's not as though decent people might start out discussing real estate or the weather, get things slightly wrong, and suddenly, to their horror, find themselves describing hard-working and successful female basketball players as 'nappy-headed hos'. That just doesn't happen.
I mean: can any of you imagine some situation in which you could find yourself using the phrase 'nappy-headed hos'? I tried, and the closest I got was imagining that I was participating in some free lice-checking program for prostitutes. Having once had to comb all the nits out of my own hair, I can imagine that the kinkiness of someone's hair might suddenly become a lot more salient than it normally is. But even then I don't think I'd use the term 'hos', or even 'whores'. And, needless to say, Imus wasn't in any such situation. He was not doing their hair. And they were not prostitutes. They were members of a basketball team who had made the NCAA title game for the first time ever, and who had done precisely nothing to bring this on, other than being black and female. Which, apparently, is enough to make the train that is Don Imus derail. And that, of course is the problem.
Here's an excerpt from their coach's statement:
"Throughout the year, these gifted young ladies set an example for the nation that through hard work and perseverance, you can accomplish anything if you believe. Without a doubt, this past season was my most rewarding in 36 years of coaching. This young team fought through immeasurable odds to reach the highest pinnacle and play for the school's first national championship in a major sport.To serve as a joke of Mr. Imus in such an insensitive manner creates a wedge and makes light of the efforts of these classy individuals, both as women and as women of color."
It was probably one of the biggest days of their lives, and he dragged them through the dirt. Thanks to Don Imus, most people will remember this team not as the team that took Rutgers to the championship, but as the team Don Imus called nappy-headed hos.
That's a terrible thing to do. It has nothing in common with a train going off the tracks. Nothing except the damage.
Don Imus deserves to be fired. He probably should have been fired quite a while ago -- say, when he called Gwen Ifill a "cleaning lady". But he should be fired now. Because some things are just not OK.
***
A few more notes:






Instead of writing about the genocide, I want to focus on Mbaye Diagne, a Senegalese military observer who was profiled in the excellent Frontline program
Recent Comments