My Photo

« The Revolution Will Be Somethinged... | Main | You can't please everyone »

January 21, 2004

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d834515c2369e200d83456282169e2

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Arar #14: A Plea for Bipartisanship in "Interesting Times":

» If This Is Not Over the Line, There Is No Line from Brad DeLong's Semi-Daily Journal (2004)
Katherine R of Obsidian Wings finishes her series of posts on the Maher Arar case: Obsidian Wings: Arar #14: A Plea for Bipartisanship in "Interesting Times": As Ted Barlow said last November, "I support the vigorous investigation and prosecution of te... [Read More]

» Maher Arar from Calpundit
MAHER ARAR....Over at Obsidian Wings, Katherine has put together a 14-part series examing what happened in the case of Maher Arar, a Canadian citizen who was seized while changing planes in New York and then sent to Syria to be... [Read More]

» Maher Arar from Thoughts Arguments and Rants
Katherine at Obsidian Wings has several more excellent posts on the Maher Arar case. Here's the editorial We don't know all the details or explanations, but we know that something terrible happened. Our government took a man from an airport in New York... [Read More]

» Maher Arar updates from Crooked Timber
Katherine at Obsidian Wings has several more excellent posts on the Maher Arar case. Here’s the editorial We don’t know all the details or explanations, but we know that something terrible happened. Our government took a man from an airport... [Read More]

» If you don't violate someone's human rights some of the time, you probably aren't doing your job from Crooked Timber
From tomorrow’s FT Six US army soldiers are facing courts-martial for abusing and humiliating Iraqi detainees - activities uncovered during an investigation that also found widespread abuses at the notorious Abu Ghraib prison, according to US mil... [Read More]

Comments

Katherine, I say again: excellent work.

Can I ask one favor: add in links to the previous 13 posts in your final one? I intend to link to this on my lj, and to spread it widely. It will be easier if it can be one link that leads to all 14 blogging posts.

Jesu--here you go:
http://obsidianwings.blogs.com/obsidian_wings/maher_arar/index.html

(You can also click "Maher Arar" under "Categories" on the right menu.)

I too want to say this entire series is excellent.

I missed numbers 12 and 13 (will go look for them now), but I still haven't figured out if the US government is denying he was tortured or not...in one place it looked like the were denying it and in another like they were admitting it happened...is this clear yet?

They haven't exactly denied it; Ashcroft has noted that Syria has said it didn't torture him, and this was consistent with their assurances before he was deported. At least one anonymous U.S. official has said that Arar was tortured (in a NY Times story.) And the only people who will outright say he wasn't are the Syrian government.

I strongly urge my non-fellow Americans to heed Katherine's advice and write to your representatives. This sort of thing isn't good for anyone of any political persuasion.

If I were a US citizen I'd be writing. It's a crying shame the papers don't seem interested; if our Government in the UK had done this, and one of the tabloids got hold of it, you wouldn't hear the end of it.

Agreed, Katherine. Good work in keeping this one alive.

I heard a story on NPR yestardy that, while much, much less heinous, is indicative of things happening in government that are Not Good.

Whether or not the woman in question did anything wrong, DoJ should not have tampered with her emails. If they've got a complaint against her, they need to take it to court.

There have been a lot of limits on civil rights since September 11. Some of them are probably necessary, but some are not; some are more or less benign, but some are dangerous.

I used to think the same thing - 'Some of them are probably necessary' - but what that kind of thinking got us was the Patriot Act, and no improvement of the intelligence apparatuses in the government. One of the things that the NRA does correctly, IMHO, is recognize a slippery slope when they see one. They consistently and forcefully (and tastelessly, often) oppose legislation of any kind that might infringe upon their 2nd Amendment right to bear arms. 9/11 was caused by a massive intelligence failure - operational and otherwise. The intelligence organizations in the U.S. and abroad had more than ample resources to prevent 9/11. It took massive negligence (criminal I'd say) to not prevent the events of that day. Jim Bovard says that nothing happened on 9/11 to make the government any more competent. I couldn't agree more. The answer to preventing another 9/11 is to fix the broken intelligence services in the US, the beaurocracy, inter-agency comm, international cooperation, etc. It is not, and should never have been, the Patriot Act. How many memos from FBI field agents had to be deliberately disappeared? It's outrageous at best. Here's hoping the near-powerless 9/11 Commission gets to more truth.



There are virtually no checks/balances left in a government that is completely dependent on those checks/balances to prevent totalitarian rule. Tommy Franks, ex-military leader/commander/warmonger/whatever, recently said something to the effect, and I'm not kidding:


One more terrorist event like 9/11 and the (US) Constitution will be suspended (aka martial law).

Repeal *all* of the Patriot Act until we can do it right!



Keep up the good work K.



For Cannucks, I bet a letter to some senior US gub officials (or those still close to them) from concerned Canadian citizens might help. Couldn't hurt. Try the Commie sympathizers like Bob Barr.

The comments to this entry are closed.

Whatnot


  • visitors since 3/2/2004

September 2014

Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
  1 2 3 4 5 6
7 8 9 10 11 12 13
14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27
28 29 30        
Blog powered by Typepad

QuantCast